I believe if a Non-VIP uses black listed mods, they should be temporarily banned for around 2 weeks... and if they are caught using them again they should be perm banned. And should still have the option to appeal there ban. now with VIP-MVP+ people, I think if they use black listed mods they should be temp banned for a week at most because they have donated to the server. If they are caught using them again they should be perm banned. But I think they should have the option for a stat wipe or to bring there rank down 1 level for an unban or maybe like you said, having a red 1 next to there name to show that they have cheated in the past. Donators should have this option because they have donated to the server and obviously love the server and do care about getting banned.